2001 North Texas (5-1), Middle Tennessee (5-1)
2002 North Texas (6-0)
2003 North Texas (7-0)
2004 North Texas (7-0)
2005 Arkansas State (5-2), La. Lafayette (5-2), La. Monroe (5-2)
2006 Middle Tennessee (6-1), Troy (6-1)
2007 Florida Atlantic (5-1) 38, Troy (6-0) 32
2008 Troy (6-1)
2009 Troy (8-0)
2010 Florida International (6-2), Troy (6-2)
2011 Arkansas State (8-0)

Sun Belt championship game results listed for 2007