1999 Brigham Young (5-2), Colorado State (5-2), Utah (5-2)
2000 Colorado State (6-1)
2001 Brigham Young (7-0)
2002 Colorado State (6-1)
2003 Utah (6-1)
2004 Utah (7-0)
2005 Texas Christian (8-0)
2006 Brigham Young (8-0)
2007 Brigham Young (8-0)
2008 Utah (8-0)
2009 Texas Christian (8-0)
2010 Texas Christian (8-0)
2011 Texas Christian (7-0)