1972

 Offense
WR-Johnny Rodgers, Nebraska
TE-Charles Young, Southern California
T-Jerry Sisemore, Texas
T-John Hicks, Ohio State
T-Paul Seymour, Michigan
G-John Hannah, Alabama
G-Skip Singletary, Temple
G-Ron Rusnak, North Carolina
C-Tom Brahaney, Oklahoma
QB-John Hufnagel, Penn State
QB-Bert Jones, Louisiana State
B-Greg Pruitt, Oklahoma
B-Dick Jauron, Yale
B-Otis Armstrong, Purdue
B-Woody Green, Arizona State

 Defense
E-Willie Harper, Nebraska
E-Bruce Bannon, Penn State
T-Dave Butz, Purdue
T-Greg Marx, Notre Dame
MG-Rich Glover, Nebraska
LB-Steve Brown, Oregon State
LB-Tom Jackson, Louisville
LB-Randy Gradishar, Ohio State
LB-Tom Skorupan, Penn State
B-Ray Guy, Southern Mississippi
B-Bob Popelka, Southern Methodist
B-Brad Van Pelt, Michigan State
B-Randy Logan, Michigan
B-Cullen Bryant, Colorado