1968

 Offense
E-Jim Seymour, Notre Dame
E-Ted Kwalick, Penn State
E-Jerry LeVias, Southern Methodist
T-Dave Foley, Ohio State
T-George Kunz, Notre Dame
G-Guy Dennis, Florida
G-Charles Rosenfelder, Tennessee
G-Mike Montler, Colorado
G-Jim Barnes, Arkansas
C-John Didion, Oregon State
QB-Terry Hanratty, Notre Dame
B-Leroy Keyes, Purdue
B-O. J. Simpson, Southern California
B-Chris Gilbert, Texas

 Defense
E-Ted Hendricks, Miami
E-Bob Stein, Minnesota
E-John Zook, Kansas
T-Bill Stanfill, Georgia
T-Joe Greene, North Texas State
MG-Chuck Kyle, Purdue
MG-Ed White, California
LB-Dennis Onkotz, Penn State
LB-Mike Hall, Alabama
LB-Steve Kiner, Tennessee
B-Jake Scott, Georgia
B-Roger Wehrli, Missouri
B-Tony Kyasky, Syracuse
S-Mike Battle, Southern California
S-Al Worley, Washington